Rubber Sheet Analogy For Warping Of Spacetime

Spacetime And Gravity Astronomy

Spacetime And Gravity Astronomy

Chapter S3 Spacetime And Gravity Ppt Download

Chapter S3 Spacetime And Gravity Ppt Download

Relativity Shock Experiments Reveal That Deformed Rubber Sheet Is Not Like Spacetime By The Physics Arxiv Blog The Physics Arxiv Blog Medium

Relativity Shock Experiments Reveal That Deformed Rubber Sheet Is Not Like Spacetime By The Physics Arxiv Blog The Physics Arxiv Blog Medium

Why Is The Rubber Sheet Analogy Used To Explain The Curvature Of Spacetime In General Relativity Wrong Quora

Why Is The Rubber Sheet Analogy Used To Explain The Curvature Of Spacetime In General Relativity Wrong Quora

Chapter S3 Spacetime And Gravity Ppt Download

Chapter S3 Spacetime And Gravity Ppt Download

Lecture 5 Curvature Of Spacetime Spacetime Curvature In The Last Lecture We Talked About Tidal Gravity And How This Bothered Einstein Greatly A Person Ppt Download

Lecture 5 Curvature Of Spacetime Spacetime Curvature In The Last Lecture We Talked About Tidal Gravity And How This Bothered Einstein Greatly A Person Ppt Download

Lecture 5 Curvature Of Spacetime Spacetime Curvature In The Last Lecture We Talked About Tidal Gravity And How This Bothered Einstein Greatly A Person Ppt Download

That pit is caused by the central mass is gravity.

Rubber sheet analogy for warping of spacetime. This in fact is an excellent analogy. In general relativity energy and mass have curvature effects on the four dimensions of the universe spacetime. Consider an equatorial slice through the black hole. If you put a mass i e the earth on the sheet the sheet will stretch out and create a pit into which other objects moons etc will fall in and orbit around.

That the warping of spacetime to produce gravity is like the deformation of a rubber sheet by a central mass. This comic refers to a common analogy used to explain how mass distorts space time a bowling ball resting on a sheet of rubber distorts the sheet due to its weight. A rubber sheet warped by a heavy stone left is an excellent analogy for a black hole s warped space right. On a flat rubber sheet a trained ant has no trouble walking in a straight line.

Figure 24 8 three dimensional analogy for spacetime. The system has some qualitative features in common with gravity. Since spacetime warping can be a difficult concept to understand and visualise an analogy is often used in physics education. A common analogy is placing a heavy object on a stretched out rubber sheet causing the sheet to bend downward.

The mechanisms behind rolling down a dent and the geodesics of spacetime are different. On a flat rubber sheet a trained ant has no trouble walking in a straight line. The similarity is that something is warping which changes the path. Figure pageindex 2 three dimensional analogy for spacetime.

Spacetime is like a rubber sheet that is flexible. When a massive object creates a big depression in the sheet the ant which must walk where the sheet takes it finds its path changed warped dramatically. When a massive object creates a big depression in the sheet the ant which must walk where the sheet takes it finds its path changed warped dramatically. The most common analogy for understanding gravity goes like this.

The way masses warp the rubber sheet and affect other smaller masses can help students develop an intuitive understanding of how gravity works under gr. It also implies that the warp is into a different dimension which is not necessary. What is the geometry of that slice. Spacetime can be thought as a thin rubber sheet.

Now physicists have tested this idea theoretically and experimentally and say it doesn t hold water. This state of affairs is almost entirely the result of one the most famous analogies in science. So the bottom line is that the rubber sheet analogy with spacetime is fundamentally flawed it simply cannot reproduce the motion that general relativity predicts. With a rubber sheet the reason things roll into the bottom of the dent is well gravity.

Stretching The Imagination How A Rubber Sheet Challenges Our Knowledge Of Gravity By Magdalena Medium

Stretching The Imagination How A Rubber Sheet Challenges Our Knowledge Of Gravity By Magdalena Medium

Why Is Space Time Drawn As A Two Dimensional Fabric When It Is Three Dimensional The Gravity Well Is Not A Dent The Gravity Well Of A Planet Sucks In Space Time From All Directions

Why Is Space Time Drawn As A Two Dimensional Fabric When It Is Three Dimensional The Gravity Well Is Not A Dent The Gravity Well Of A Planet Sucks In Space Time From All Directions

Free Fall In Curved Spacetime Titan Uio No

Free Fall In Curved Spacetime Titan Uio No

General Relativity What S Wrong With The Rubber Sheet Analogy Quora

General Relativity What S Wrong With The Rubber Sheet Analogy Quora

Is The Bowling Ball On A Rubber Membrane A Useful Analogy For How Gravity Affects Spacetime Quora

Is The Bowling Ball On A Rubber Membrane A Useful Analogy For How Gravity Affects Spacetime Quora

What Does Spacetime Look Like Near A Black Hole Physics Stack Exchange

What Does Spacetime Look Like Near A Black Hole Physics Stack Exchange

Spacetime In Empty Space With Only One Body If Another Mass Was Suddenly Introduced Say Via Conversion From Energy Why Would The Two Start Moving Towards Each Other Quora

Spacetime In Empty Space With Only One Body If Another Mass Was Suddenly Introduced Say Via Conversion From Energy Why Would The Two Start Moving Towards Each Other Quora

This Would Be Sooo Fun Physics Humor Science Humor Physics

This Would Be Sooo Fun Physics Humor Science Humor Physics

Why Is Spacetime Shown On A 2 Dimensional Plane Physics Forums

Why Is Spacetime Shown On A 2 Dimensional Plane Physics Forums

Of Warps And Ripples The Dilemma Of Space Time And The Quanta The Elegant Universe Superstrings Hidden Dimensions And The Quest For The Ultimate Theory Brian Greene

Of Warps And Ripples The Dilemma Of Space Time And The Quanta The Elegant Universe Superstrings Hidden Dimensions And The Quest For The Ultimate Theory Brian Greene

Einstein S Second Revolution Movement On The Surface Of The Earth Is Limited To Two Dimensions Forward Backward And Left Right Or N S And E W However Ppt Download

Einstein S Second Revolution Movement On The Surface Of The Earth Is Limited To Two Dimensions Forward Backward And Left Right Or N S And E W However Ppt Download

4 0 General Relativity

4 0 General Relativity

Relativity Students Britannica Kids Homework Help

Relativity Students Britannica Kids Homework Help

Build Your Own Space Time Warping Demo For The Classroom The Kid Should See This

Build Your Own Space Time Warping Demo For The Classroom The Kid Should See This

Ppt Lecture 15 General Theory Of Relativity Powerpoint Presentation Free Download Id 1358301

Ppt Lecture 15 General Theory Of Relativity Powerpoint Presentation Free Download Id 1358301

What Is It In The Nature Of Light Which Has No Mass That Allows It To Be Bent By Gravity Quora

What Is It In The Nature Of Light Which Has No Mass That Allows It To Be Bent By Gravity Quora

What Is The Best Way To Imagine Space Time Quora

What Is The Best Way To Imagine Space Time Quora

Does Pluto S Crazy Orbit Question The Legitimacy Of The Theory Of Spacetime Warp Why Does Pluto Have Such A Highly Inclined Orbit Around The Sun If All The Planets Are Trapped In

Does Pluto S Crazy Orbit Question The Legitimacy Of The Theory Of Spacetime Warp Why Does Pluto Have Such A Highly Inclined Orbit Around The Sun If All The Planets Are Trapped In

Https Encrypted Tbn0 Gstatic Com Images Q Tbn 3aand9gcsndhjjqjlbdwxcmlmir Oej8bumjrwu Ufxqbhcmowp80b Aa Usqp Cau

Https Encrypted Tbn0 Gstatic Com Images Q Tbn 3aand9gcsndhjjqjlbdwxcmlmir Oej8bumjrwu Ufxqbhcmowp80b Aa Usqp Cau

In General Relativity If Spacetime Is Curved Relative To A Flatspace What Is The Flatspace And How Would You Describe It Quora

In General Relativity If Spacetime Is Curved Relative To A Flatspace What Is The Flatspace And How Would You Describe It Quora

Intro To General Relativity Ppt Download

Intro To General Relativity Ppt Download

Https Academics Uccs Edu Rtirado Pes 1060 Astro 2 Bennett 8e S3 Lectureoutline Pdf

Https Academics Uccs Edu Rtirado Pes 1060 Astro 2 Bennett 8e S3 Lectureoutline Pdf

Is It Possible To Tell The Difference Between Gravity And Warped Spacetime Quora

Is It Possible To Tell The Difference Between Gravity And Warped Spacetime Quora

Do Black Holes Pull In And Keep Spacetime Itself Or Merely Warp It But Ultimately Let It Pass Through Astronomy Stack Exchange

Do Black Holes Pull In And Keep Spacetime Itself Or Merely Warp It But Ultimately Let It Pass Through Astronomy Stack Exchange

How Can Any Celestial Object Leave An Imprint On The Fabric Of Space If There Is No Up Or Down Wouldn T Gravity Be Affecting It On All Sides Therefore Not Causing It

How Can Any Celestial Object Leave An Imprint On The Fabric Of Space If There Is No Up Or Down Wouldn T Gravity Be Affecting It On All Sides Therefore Not Causing It

What Does Spacetime Look Like Quora

What Does Spacetime Look Like Quora

Http Astroweb Case Edu Agnes 211 09 Cosmic5 Pdf

Http Astroweb Case Edu Agnes 211 09 Cosmic5 Pdf

Physically What Does Warping Of Space Time Mean Physics Stack Exchange

Physically What Does Warping Of Space Time Mean Physics Stack Exchange

If Gravity Is A Result Of Space Time Warping Then Why Is Space Time Warping Downwards Quora

If Gravity Is A Result Of Space Time Warping Then Why Is Space Time Warping Downwards Quora

Gravity And Curvature Of Space Time Ilovephilosophy Com

Gravity And Curvature Of Space Time Ilovephilosophy Com

Comparison With Newton S Perception Of Gravity Elwyn S Big Bang Page

Comparison With Newton S Perception Of Gravity Elwyn S Big Bang Page

The Speed Of Gravity What The Experiments Say

The Speed Of Gravity What The Experiments Say

Why Does Gtr Not Need A Higher Dimension To Describe The Bending Of Spacetime Physics Stack Exchange

Why Does Gtr Not Need A Higher Dimension To Describe The Bending Of Spacetime Physics Stack Exchange

Http Astroweb Case Edu Agnes 211 09 Cosmic4 Pdf

Http Astroweb Case Edu Agnes 211 09 Cosmic4 Pdf

Beyond The Event Horizon Blackhols

Beyond The Event Horizon Blackhols

Curvature Of Spacetime As A Real Thing Physics Stack Exchange

Curvature Of Spacetime As A Real Thing Physics Stack Exchange

Many Worlds But Too Much Metaphor

Many Worlds But Too Much Metaphor

A Wrinkle In Spacetime Physics Article For Students Scholastic Science World Magazine

A Wrinkle In Spacetime Physics Article For Students Scholastic Science World Magazine

Why Did The Apple Fall A New Model To Explain Einstein S Gravity Request Pdf

Why Did The Apple Fall A New Model To Explain Einstein S Gravity Request Pdf

Publications Magdalena Kersting Science Education

Publications Magdalena Kersting Science Education

Https Www Duo Uio No Bitstream Handle 10852 74677 Kersting 2019 Phys Educ 54 035008 Pdf Sequence 4

Https Www Duo Uio No Bitstream Handle 10852 74677 Kersting 2019 Phys Educ 54 035008 Pdf Sequence 4

Akxfyizve51zvm

Akxfyizve51zvm

If Gravity Is Because Of The Curvature Of Space Time What Kind Of Curvature Is Responsible For The Attraction On The Earth S Surface For Example How Are Human Beings Attracted To The

If Gravity Is Because Of The Curvature Of Space Time What Kind Of Curvature Is Responsible For The Attraction On The Earth S Surface For Example How Are Human Beings Attracted To The

Https Encrypted Tbn0 Gstatic Com Images Q Tbn 3aand9gcqq9sulofmmgrxccnkywkogxrbnxi0 Wke0tbhfrijyuucp Z7g Usqp Cau

Https Encrypted Tbn0 Gstatic Com Images Q Tbn 3aand9gcqq9sulofmmgrxccnkywkogxrbnxi0 Wke0tbhfrijyuucp Z7g Usqp Cau

Source : pinterest.com